一亩三分地论坛

 找回密码
 获取更多干货,去instant注册!

扫码关注一亩三分地公众号
查看: 649|回复: 1
收起左侧

Reviewer坑爹

[复制链接] |试试Instant~ |关注本帖
heguanda2 发表于 2015-2-21 03:56:41 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式

注册一亩三分地论坛,查看更多干货!

您需要 登录 才可以下载或查看,没有帐号?获取更多干货,去instant注册!

x
这学期投了篇APL,运气不好,被分到了两个reviewer,昨天出了结果。
第一个reviewer早早的交了review,给了minor revision。第二个哥们拖拖拉拉,搞了一个多月才搞定。结果这个B看了一个半月毛都没看懂,给了poor,真是坑爹!. From 1point 3acres bbs
还好主编明鉴,采用了第一个reviewer的意见,擦
你们看看这第二个哥们
Reviewer #2 Evaluations:
RECOMMENDATION: Reject
Paper Interesting: No
Original Paper: Yes
Sufficient Physics: No
Well Organized: No
Clear and Error Free: No
Conclusions Supported: No
Appropriate Title: Yes
Good Abstract: No
Satisfactory English: Yes . 1point 3acres 璁哄潧
Adequate References: No
Clear Figures: Yes
OVERALL RATING: Poor

Reviewer #2 (Comments to the Author):

The authors describe impedometric analysis for artificial sweat in order to characterize human sweat in terms of the electrical variation upon the changes of electrolyte composition. In the paper the impedance measurement for the artificial sweat, and home-made conductometric sweat sensor were demonstrated. Sweat analysis and its sensory systems have been studied for more than a century, and there are lots of sweat sensors providing much information for human body with ease-of-use manner. It is ambiguous what this work aims, and inconsistent in the experimental work flow; at the first they claimed to analyze liquid electrolytes with impedometry, and then they suddenly fabricated tubular test sensor for sweat detection. i think this paper has lack of scientific interest, and even premature for publication anywhere. I don't recommend it for publication in APL.
还EVEN premature for publication anywhere, 我真是想要抽他......
iwlam525 发表于 2015-2-21 08:20:21 | 显示全部楼层
哈哈…貌似的确木有肿么看懂的样子唉
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

本版积分规则

请点这里访问我们的新网站:一亩三分地Instant.

Instant搜索更强大,不扣积分,内容组织的更好更整洁!目前仍在beta版本,努力完善中!反馈请点这里

关闭

一亩三分地推荐上一条 /5 下一条

手机版|小黑屋|一亩三分地论坛声明 ( 沪ICP备11015994号 )

custom counter

GMT+8, 2016-12-6 11:30

Powered by Discuz! X3

© 2001-2013 Comsenz Inc. Design By HUXTeam

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表