查看: 1731|回复: 18

[OPT] 不知道大家有没有注意到John Miano此人的评论

[复制链接] |试试Instant~ |关注本帖
JESSIE5590 发表于 2015-11-12 06:06:47 | 显示全部楼层 |阅读模式


您需要 登录 才可以下载或查看,没有帐号?获取更多干货,去instant注册!

如果从已经po出来的评论里面搜索John Miano,就会搜到他发的五篇连载评论,. visit 1point3acres.com for more.
http://www.regulations.gov/#!documentDetail;D=ICEB-2015-0002-9802. Waral 鍗氬鏈夋洿澶氭枃绔,

其中一条他的论点4. The opt program runs contrary to the purpose of non-immigrant student visas.中他引用了各位的评论来论证我们的移民倾向。
. 涓浜-涓夊垎-鍦帮紝鐙鍙戝竷
. 鐣欏鐢宠璁哄潧-涓浜╀笁鍒嗗湴
John Miano, attorney representing tech workers:. 鐗涗汉浜戦泦,涓浜╀笁鍒嗗湴

the proposed rule effectively "requires employers and universities to engage in unlawful immigration status discrimination."
"The rule requires these organizations to set up mentoring programs for foreign graduates to work under OPT. However, there is no requirement that American graduates receive the same benefit."

You should read the reports of John Miano who has studied the H-1B visa program intensively in recent years. See his reports listed here: http://cis.org/Miano-Publications

. Waral 鍗氬鏈夋洿澶氭枃绔,此人的评论大家需要引起重视,一起围观反驳起来!




felixstar 发表于 2015-11-13 14:56:56 | 显示全部楼层
Reponse to John Miano's comments:ICEB-2015-0002-9797;ICEB-2015-0002-9801;ICEB-2015-0002-9802;ICEB-2015-0002-9807;ICEB-2015-0002-9808.

1. Response to "DHS did not consider all the options."
. 鍥磋鎴戜滑@1point 3 acres
The OPT program has been existing for long time (including STEM & non-STEM). The termination of an existing program would result in significant impact on the students that are already studying in US or have just finished degrees in US, as well as the companies that hired students in OPT for crucial work. If this needs to be re-evaluated, there should be a smooth transition process. For example, it should not be terminated at least within five years (a normal PhD period) to mitigate the impact.

2. Response to "The OPT program is a solution in search of a problem."
. more info on 1point3acres.com
The introduction of 2008 OPT Rule "may be" due to the loopholes in the H1B visa system. A recent article by New York Times "Large Companies Game H-1B Visa Program, Costing the U.S. Jobs" exactly describes the root cause of this problem. Before the congress fixing the H1B visa loopholes, the US industry requires a solution to maintain the continuity of economic development. Unfortunately there has been a deadlock on fixing the H1B system due to political fights between the two parties, making this ruling a really needed solution to stabilize the labor market..鐣欏璁哄潧-涓浜-涓夊垎鍦

3. Response to "DHS is just going through the motions in this rulemaking process."
The DHS is fixing its neglect of notice and comment in 2008 Rule. It should be appreciated that DHS is doing everything they can do to reduce the turbulance on labor market, otherwise many companies would fail to hire the qualified employees and have to outsource all jobs.

4. Response to "The OPT program runs contrary to the purpose of non-immigrant student visas".
Again, if the DHS needs to re-evaluate the appropriateness of OPT program, they need to ensure there is a smooth transition process and fix the loopholes in the US work authorization program for foreigners first, to avoid the abrupt interruption of US economy.

5. Response to "The proposed rule will make it harder to get H-1B visas":
This may not be true. The difficulty to get H-1B visa is largely not caused by the number of students in US, but the abuse of H-1B system by large outsourcing companies, which not only caused the difficulty for all students in US to get a job or obtain a visa to qualify for the job, but also eventually shift jobs away from US. The international students receiving education in US need to be protected, rather than blamed. . 涓浜-涓夊垎-鍦帮紝鐙鍙戝竷

6. Response to "Educational Purpose"
There are indeed educational purpose for the OPT program. I myself found the industry working experience significantly deepened my understanding of the research topic that I worked on campus. This is because: (1) The academic world in general do not have the advantage of obtaing real data; (2)Students usually could not obtain the state-of-the-art studying materials or tools, which are usually proprietary information in the industry. The OPT program indeed benefit foreign students not only learning the theoretical knowledge but also learning the practical skills to deepen the grasp of knowledge and research.

Again, even if the DHS needs to re-evaluate the appropriateness of OPT program, they need to ensure there is a smooth transition process and fix the loopholes in the US work authorization program for foreigners first, to avoid the abrupt interuption of US economy..鏈枃鍘熷垱鑷1point3acres璁哄潧

7. Response to "Industry has no expertise to establish mentoring program".
This may not be true. Many companies even have the more appropriate and specialized elites to guide students in practice than the professors in school which are mostly good at theory.

8. Response to "The proposed OPT program runs afoul of anti-discrimination provisions."
This is easy fix that the American students can be entitled the same benefit of mentoring program as well.. 1point 3acres 璁哄潧

9. Response to "The new protections for American workers are useless."
The rule indeed needs to come with a much stricter review of the job offers to avoid the abuse of the program.
10. Response to "The Proposed Rule ignores the impact on American workers and "STEM" graduates."
First of all, there is no evidence showing that half of American graduates in "STEM" fields could not find jobs in "STEM" field. Even it is the fact, it is unclear if this is simply because they choose to find jobs outside the "STEM" field rather than because of the competition with international students. Even if it is due to the competition with international students, it is unclear if American graduates are lacking behind international students in the required skills for the jobs in "STEM" fields.

. 涓浜-涓夊垎-鍦帮紝鐙鍙戝竷Second, the comparison with international students and American students actually will stimulate the investment in the elementary education in "STEM" field in US, which is known to be lacking behind than many other countries. Driving international graduates away sounds not a right solution to improve the quality of American education or getting the most advanced skills for the US companies.

11. Response to "The allowance of unemployment on OPT is inconsistent with education and protections for U.S. workers."
This allowance of unemployment can be revised.

12. Response to "DHS cannot justify the increased duration of OPT."
"The average time a new graduate stays at a first job is only 18 months" (not sure where is the source) doesn't mean the required training is only 18 months or the graduate has switched to a different area after 18 months. There are multiple reasons for a new graduate to leave the first job, such as bad company culture, better opportunities or simply personal reasons. The training may be continued with different companies but in a same field.

To my experience, without staying on a job for about at least 3 years, one won't have deep understanding about the research project to become a specialist in the field.. 鍥磋鎴戜滑@1point 3 acres

13. Response to "DHS relies on bad information in the proposed rule"
If this is true, DHS may need to better substantiate the conclusion, but this doesn't undermine the need of this proposed rule in the current situation-- broken work-authorization program abused by a few outsourcing companies, but shortage of talents for all rest of companies.

14. Response to "The proposed rule creates national security issues". from: 1point3acres.com/bbs
With better monitoring of students and reviewing of job offers, this can be avoided. .鏈枃鍘熷垱鑷1point3acres璁哄潧

15. Response to " The proposed rule will discourage Americans to study in technology fields"
This is likely false. The new proposed rule will attract more international talents in STEM field. From my own experience, I learn from someone that are more excellent than myself. I don't think Americans are so easy to be discouraged if the ones remained in US are truly talents. Again, the true issue causing the discourage is the large amount of "non-talents" brought by Indian outsourcing companies who are abusing the H-1B system. Instead, the talented students that study in US should be encouraged to stay. Without the OPT extension ruling or a fix of the H-1B system, the US job market will be filled by these "machine-like" technicians from outsourcing companies, which not only discourage talents to come to US but also discourage Americans to study in these majors.




回复 支持 3 反对 0

使用道具 举报

guo72 发表于 2015-11-13 09:58:04 | 显示全部楼层
回复 支持 3 反对 0

使用道具 举报

johnM 发表于 2015-11-12 06:10:17 | 显示全部楼层
he has the first name as mine.....
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

qingbinlee 发表于 2015-11-12 06:44:39 | 显示全部楼层

只training stem国际学生不training stem美国人,好多美国人也提到了,主要就得看dhs如何去表述。给国际学生提供training的可能与给国际学生提供training是有区别的。.1point3acres缃

这个人没有涉及opt对于留学人数吸引上,这个是重要缺陷,根据我看comments,很多人提到如果没有opt 就不来美国了,这个点可以打击。
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

forever2xxx 发表于 2015-11-12 10:46:45 | 显示全部楼层
感觉high level能扯的都扯了 下一步就是要看别人的评论填补漏洞-google 1point3acres
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

AnakinFoxe 发表于 2015-11-12 12:54:08 | 显示全部楼层
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

jeff_xu001 发表于 2015-11-12 13:01:22 | 显示全部楼层
johnM 发表于 2015-11-12 06:10
he has the first name as mine.....

not you? are u sure?

Guess that‘s you in fact

anyway,各人都有自己的利益,fair enough

no offence
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

johnM 发表于 2015-11-12 13:10:11 | 显示全部楼层
jeff_xu001 发表于 2015-11-12 13:01. 1point3acres.com/bbs
not you? are u sure?

Guess that‘s you in fact
. more info on 1point3acres.com
I do not think that John Miano knows Chinese and if I were him, why will I post comments to remind you guys?
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

jeff_xu001 发表于 2015-11-12 13:18:47 | 显示全部楼层
johnM 发表于 2015-11-12 13:10
I do not think that John Miano knows Chinese and if I were him, why will I post comments to remind ...

嗯, just coincidence, John M.

sorry for that
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

trustyou 发表于 2015-11-12 14:20:58 | 显示全部楼层
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

dabinzi 发表于 2015-11-12 15:17:23 | 显示全部楼层
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

AnakinFoxe 发表于 2015-11-13 01:50:25 | 显示全部楼层

回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

yongmat 发表于 2015-11-13 02:04:42 | 显示全部楼层
如果他们觉得opt不交税是经济损失,那么他们应该去号召定法案让opt交税,而不是取消opt。. 鐣欏鐢宠璁哄潧-涓浜╀笁鍒嗗湴
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

 楼主| JESSIE5590 发表于 2015-11-13 02:14:57 | 显示全部楼层
AnakinFoxe 发表于 2015-11-13 01:50
搜索了一下发现这家伙就是cis.org的一个主要的专栏作者。而cis.org就是一个鼓吹减少移民数量的非营利性组织 ...

回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

chouclee 发表于 2015-11-13 02:58:15 | 显示全部楼层
yongmat 发表于 2015-11-13 02:04 鏉ユ簮涓浜.涓夊垎鍦拌鍧.
实际上这个延长法案对于有移民倾向的留学生不一定是有利的,企业可能一直拖着不办H1B,直到你的opt消耗完, ...

回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

为延期而注册 发表于 2015-11-13 07:55:04 | 显示全部楼层
GRE argrment重现,一条一条来...
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

jeff_xu001 发表于 2015-11-13 09:16:11 | 显示全部楼层
dabinzi 发表于 2015-11-12 15:17. from: 1point3acres.com/bbs

incremental吧, 别想着 fundamental change了,民主国家,各种利益要博弈, compromise的
回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报

金妮韦崽 发表于 2015-11-13 15:15:33 | 显示全部楼层

回复 支持 反对

使用道具 举报





一亩三分地推荐上一条 /5 下一条

手机版|小黑屋|一亩三分地论坛声明 ( 沪ICP备11015994号 )

custom counter

GMT+8, 2017-1-22 22:44

Powered by Discuz! X3

© 2001-2013 Comsenz Inc. Design By HUXTeam

快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表