📣 黑五价提前开抢|VIP一年通行证5折,蓝莓、Offer多多同步特惠
查看: 2599| 回复: 6
跳转到指定楼层
上一主题 下一主题
收起左侧

[职场感言] H1B NOID on multiple H1B registrations -> approval [Thomas Vinu Allen]

🔗
匿名用户-W2NHM  | 添加认证 | 2023-7-6 11:11:33 来自APP |倒序浏览

注册一亩三分地论坛,查看更多干货!

您需要 登录 才可以下载或查看附件。没有帐号?注册账号

x
本帖最后由 匿名 于 2023-7-6 03:36 编辑
-baidu 1point3acres
Thomas Vinu Allen. 1point 3 acres
巧合是,这个律师所是 去年 Nov. 2022 左右第一批发现NOID  on multiple H1B registrations@FY2023 的律所。
https://redbus2us.com/uscis-noid-h1b-multiple-registrations/
https://www.1point3acres.com/bbs/thread-943715-1-1.html
但不清楚post中提及的H1B NOID on multiple H1B registrations -> approval是FY2023还是FY2024.
虽然都有60%  increase in terms of numbers, 对于FY2023与FY2024不同的还有
  • stoph1babuse那个lawsuit在Feb. 2022被驳回 以及
  • USCIS并没有在2022年4-6月及时对于FY2023做出多少操作(如果不是完全没有的话),
  • 甚至2023年4月底之前multiple h1b registations相关数据基本没有(如果不是完全没有的话).--

如果USCIS去年就操作,那FY2024也不会继续+60%了;是USCIS 2022年明显没给出多少负责任信号——估计USCIS最关心的是不要影响registration费用带来的revenue。
Approval of H-1B where NOID was issued on multiple H-1B CAP registration alleging fraud and misrepresentation.Our office represented an employer who received a NOID alleging fraud and misrepresentation on multiple registration issues. USCIS identified overlapping registrations for the beneficiary along with other candidates with another company.
Among other things, our office challenged the USCIS authority to impose an attestation requirement that is not supported by any immigration law or regulation. We addressed the issue by pointing out the existing rules that permit multiple registrations by unrelated companies.-baidu 1point3acres
Remarkably, within a month of submitting our response to the NOID, the USCIS granted approval for the H-1B case. This outcome demonstrates the success of our argument and our conviction that USCIS erred in implementing the new attestation requirement restricting multiple CAP registration.
Hope USCIS will follow the proper rule-making process to restrict multiple registrations for the next fiscal year.

补充内容 (2023-07-06 11:51 +08:00):

时不时看到有印度attorney问那些(比方白人,但我至少在这里不太racism)attorney,那什么multiple H1B registration是可以的?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEEtWI7ckVw
答曰:你拿到Google, FB, MSFT offer这互不相干可以同时file——好像这挺体面。-baidu 1point3acres

USCIS让他们自己美国人拿Google, FB, MSFT offer,然后因为h1b 问题只file一个(比方FB),其他家撕(Google, MSFT)offer去?USCIS用这中corrupted game system玩我们劳苦大众,哪些attorney还来几个“互不相干可以同时file”讲得体面——还有脸说在那为了h1b撕多个offer?.google  и

补充内容 (2023-07-21 09:25 +08:00):



https://thomasvallen.com/crimina...uld-fail-miserably/

补充内容 (2023-07-21 15:51 +08:00):

https://www.linkedin.com/feed/up...9542719856943104%29

上一篇:昨晚梦到朋友给我吐槽icc
下一篇:随着threads的发布,meta员工是不是又赢麻了
全局:
正义或许会迟到,但绝不会缺席
回复

使用道具 举报

地里匿名用户
🔗
匿名用户-W2NHM  | 添加认证 | 2023-7-6 16:34:38
fireworks74 发表于 2023-7-6 03:32
正义或许会迟到,但绝不会缺席

三年前就是这么想的,等到opt用完还不见得好正常人能等多久?难道等到被裁?

stoph1babuse lawsuit去年Feb. 2022 被驳回。
回复

使用道具 举报

地里匿名用户
🔗
匿名用户-W2NHM  | 添加认证 | 2023-7-17 12:16:08
本帖最后由 匿名 于 2023-7-17 04:19 编辑

https://thomasvallen.com/criminal-prosecution-for-multiple-h-1b-registrations-why-uscis-would-fail-miserably/

There is no doubt that the new registration process implemented by USCIS failed miserably due to significant flaws which opened doors for abuse and misuse of the immigration system by unscrupulous employers. . 1point3acres.com
With a minimum registration fee of $10 per applicant and a registration form which requires minimal information of the applicant, the process was supposed to fail even before its implementation. . ----
The employers exploited the inadequacy of the registration process by filing the same applicants through their related companies and through their acquaintances companies to increase the chances of selection of their candidates.  At the same time the candidates looked for multiple employers to register for them to increase their chances of selection in the lottery.  
The race to get more candidates into the lottery system by the employers and the candidate’s desperation to get into the lottery system by filing through multiple companies led to the collapse of the registration system as the number of registrations exploded to more than 780,000 for the fiscal year 2024.
Rather than acknowledging the abuse by both employers and candidates, USCIS initially denied any flaws in the system, even when confronted with a lawsuit filed by 300 applicants in 2020. The agency rejected all allegations, refusing to accept responsibility.
In 2021, USCIS attempted to address the issue with an attestation requiring employers to declare under penalty of perjury that they were not colluding with others to increase their candidates' chances of selection. However, this measure failed to deter employers and candidates from continuing to file multiple registrations.
Starting in October 2022, USCIS began issuing Notices of Intent to Deny and Notices of Intent to Revoke for multiple registrations, alleging fraud, misrepresentation, and violation of the attestation's terms. Despite these actions, the abuse of the H-1B registration process persisted, with the number of registrations nearly doubling in 2023.
Finally, in May 2023, USCIS announced its intention to refer abusers for criminal prosecution.
But undoubtedly, USCIS will face significant challenges and will fail miserably in initiating criminal prosecution or effectively preventing multiple registrations under the existing rules and regulations.
The initial regulation on H-1B cap registration was properly implemented through a rule making process and the regulation permitted multiple registration through different companies.  The regulation reads, “USCIS will accept more than one registration for the same beneficiary so long as each registration relates to a different employer”.  If the USCIS wanted to restrict multiple registrations, they should have followed the proper rule making process.  Instead, the agency came up with a new attestation under penalty of perjury that the employers cannot collude with one another to increase the chances of selection in the lottery.  The penalty of perjury is punishable with a fine and 5 years of imprisonment.  But the USCIS will fail in its attempt to bring charges against these employers under penalty of perjury.  According to U.S Code Title 28, for the agency to require an attestation under penalty of perjury, the subject matter that is being attested must be to establish a matter that is required under any law of the U.S., or any rule, regulation, order, or requirement made pursuant to law. But there is no regulation that prohibits multiple registration and on the contrary the original regulation allows multiple registration by different employers.  In the absence of any law or regulation or even a memorandum, the USCISs implementation of attestation is flawed.  Any US attorney would hesitate to take this matter up for criminal prosecution.   . ----
Prohibiting multiple registration requires rule making.  The existing regulations do support multiple registrations.  The Matter of S-Inc, which was adopted by the USCIS and the 8 CFR 214.2(H)(2)(1)(G) clearly states that related companies can file multiple H-1Bs for the same beneficiary if there is a legitimate business need.  If the regulations and the USCIS policies permit multiple H-1B filing, with the prohibition on multiple registration, how would related employers file multiple registrations if there is a legitimate business need. So, the current regulations and the USCIS new attestation requirements contradict significantly.   
The USCIS alleges fraud and misrepresentation in the NOIDs and NOIRs.  However, the regulation that they are quoting alleging fraud and misrepresentation does not apply to the employers.  The regulation says an alien may not commit fraud or misrepresentation to obtain an immigration benefit.  USCISs allegation is that the employers are committing fraud.  USCIS is quoting the wrong statute.  The fraud and misrepresentation allegation won’t survive the test of law.       . .и
The registration system for H-1B visas is fundamentally flawed. According to the regulations, if multiple H-1B petitions are filed for the same beneficiary, only one visa number should be allotted. However, when the same beneficiary is selected through multiple companies, multiple visa numbers are allocated to that individual. This leads to a wastage of visa numbers, as beneficiaries who are selected through multiple companies end up filing their H-1B petitions through a single company, resulting in the loss of the remaining visa numbers. Consequently, very few people are actually selected in the lottery despite the high number of registrations.   
The lack of transparency from USCIS further exacerbates the problem. It is unclear whether the unused visa numbers are allocated to the next fiscal year or if they simply go to waste. This ambiguity adds to the inefficiency and unfairness of the current system.   
The USCISs promulgation of restriction of multiple registrations shows the lack of personals in the agency with legal knowledge or willful ignorance of the laws which they have always taken in for granted. But the Executive Orders and unlawful memos and rejections have left the agency vulnerable as lawsuits flooded courts and employers and beneficiaries are no longer scared to take the agency to the court. . 1point3acres.com
The current flawed method of implementation of restrictions on multiple registrations by USCIS indicates a potential lack of personnel within the agency who possess sufficient legal knowledge or may demonstrate willful ignorance of the laws that they have previously taken for granted. The issuance of Executive Orders, unlawful memos, and denials during Trump era has left the agency vulnerable to legal challenges as an increasing number of lawsuits flooded the courts. Employers and beneficiaries are no longer hesitant to take legal action against the agency. The current issuance of Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID) and subsequent denials by USCIS is expected to put a strain on the courts, as it is likely to result in numerous lawsuits. The increased number of NOIDs and denials could lead to a significant caseload for the courts, as individuals and employers seek legal remedies to challenge these decisions.
It is crucial for the agency, USCIS, to undertake a comprehensive revamp of the existing regulations governing the cap registration process in order to effectively address the abuses within the system. Furthermore, USCIS must ensure strict adherence to the rules and regulations in their efforts to prevent multiple registrations. Upholding the integrity of the immigration system is a shared responsibility among employers, employees, lawyers, and USCIS. By collectively upholding the principles and regulations that govern the system, we can maintain a fair and transparent immigration process for the benefit of all individuals involved.
回复

使用道具 举报

地里匿名用户
🔗
匿名用户-AX20M  | 添加认证 | 2023-7-17 13:02:30
最近好像确实没什么新的被查的dp了
回复

使用道具 举报

地里匿名用户
🔗
匿名用户-AX20M  | 添加认证 | 2023-7-20 05:28:33
https://www.1point3acres.com/bbs/thread-1005442-1-1.html

根据油管大反贼https://youtu.be/_e91KGQV5kg只要人还在美国 感觉可以联系这个律师抢救一下lol
回复

使用道具 举报

地里匿名用户
🔗
匿名用户-W2NHM  | 添加认证 | 2023-7-21 16:33:06
本帖最后由 匿名 于 2023-7-21 08:39 编辑 . 1point 3acres
.
如下professional argument:https://thomasvallen.com/crimina ... uld-fail-miserably/
According to U.S Code Title 28, for the agency to require an attestation under penalty of perjury, the subject matter that is being attested must be to establish a matter that is required under any law of the U.S., or any rule, regulation, order, or requirement made pursuant to law.  But there is no regulation that prohibits multiple registration and on the contrary the original regulation allows multiple registration by different employers.  In the absence of any law or regulation or even a memorandum, the USCISs implementation of attestation is flawed.  Any US attorney would hesitate to take this matter up for criminal prosecution.  
Prohibiting multiple registration requires rule making. The existing regulations do support multiple registrations.  The Matter of S-Inc, which was adopted by the USCIS and the 8 CFR 214.2(H)(2)(1)(G) clearly states that related companies can file multiple H-1Bs for the same beneficiary if there is a legitimate business need.  If the regulations and the USCIS policies permit multiple H-1B filing, with the prohibition on multiple registration, how would related employers file multiple registrations if there is a legitimate business need.  So, the current regulations and the USCIS new attestation requirements contradict significantly.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/1746. Waral dи,
https://www.uscis.gov/sites/defa ... ecision-Package.pdf
回复

使用道具 举报

您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册账号
职场达人
  • ↑ 本版用于讨论职场各种干货话题,闲聊请去🔗聊聊或者🔗匿名版
  • ❌ 本版严禁水贴,引战,发布广告,拉群,贴个人联系方式,扣分无警告
  • ☑ 求职、面经等去 🔗北美求职和 🔗回国求职大区,刷题和学习请去 🔗终身学习大区
  • ☑ 请去专版发布 🔗内推, 🔗招聘信息,和讨论 🔗创业内容
  • ☑ PIP / DevList/ Need Support 等话题也已开设 🔗专版

本版积分规则

>
快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表