📣 黑五价提前开抢|VIP一年通行证5折,蓝莓、Offer多多同步特惠
楼主: 匿名
跳转到指定楼层
上一主题 下一主题
收起左侧

[公民/入美籍] Trump行政令剥夺合法移民子女出生公民权

   
🔗
xjian77 2025-1-21 12:24:27 | 只看该作者
全局:
Haider 发表于 2025-1-20 23:16
明天第九巡回法院上班后应该就会发injunction来给川普解释了😂

案子已经在New Hampshire了。那是第一巡回法院的地盘,Jackson法官管辖。
https://www.msn.com/en-us/politi ... zenship/ar-AA1xyJz5
回复

使用道具 举报

🔗
dpu2024 2025-1-21 12:26:57 | 只看该作者
全局:
pyayuhg 发表于 2025-1-20 19:21
感觉太荒唐了
婴儿在美国连身份保障都没有
人道主义灾难

东大上海出生还不是照样打回原籍办户口. 你以为上海生就有上海户口? 美帝向东大看齐
回复

使用道具 举报

🔗
Fussy_Trainer 2025-1-21 12:27:29 | 只看该作者
全局:
本帖最后由 Fussy_Trainer 于 2025-1-20 23:30 编辑

看大家的总结大概率是会被诉讼了,这里贴一个chatgpt的回复供参考。大概的意思是在等待法院决定期间birthright还是有效力,不知道这个答复是否准确。

Under the current interpretation of the **14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution**, **children born on U.S. soil automatically acquire American citizenship**, regardless of the immigration status of their parents. This principle, often referred to as "birthright citizenship," is a longstanding precedent.

If the new executive order is challenged in court and its implementation is stalled, **the existing legal framework remains in place during the legal proceedings.** This means that children born in the United States during this period should still be considered U.S. citizens at birth under current law.

However, it's worth noting that:

1. **Future Legal Outcomes**: If the courts eventually uphold changes to birthright citizenship or reinterpret the 14th Amendment, there could be retrospective legal implications, although such retroactivity is uncommon in U.S. law.

2. **Legal Challenges**: Immigrant rights advocates often argue that executive actions cannot unilaterally alter constitutional principles like birthright citizenship without congressional legislation or constitutional amendments. Such a challenge would likely delay any enforcement of changes.

Thus, as of now, children born during the period when the executive order is stalled should retain birthright citizenship, barring any unexpected shifts in judicial rulings or constitutional interpretation.
回复

使用道具 举报

全局:
没事 阿三们更急
回复

使用道具 举报

🔗
Haider 2025-1-21 12:29:26 | 只看该作者
全局:
xjian77 发表于 2025-1-21 12:24
案子已经在New Hampshire了。那是第一巡回法院的地盘,Jackson法官管辖。
https://www.msn.com/en-us/po ...

感觉也没差
回复

使用道具 举报

全局:
川粉求锤得锤, 喜大普奔。
回复

使用道具 举报

🔗
hpyyy 2025-1-21 12:31:14 来自APP | 只看该作者
全局:
dpu2024 发表于 2025-01-20 20:26:57
东大上海出生还不是照样打回原籍办户口. 你以为上海生就有上海户口? 美帝向东大看齐
其实大部分地方都是这样的,美国属于另类
回复

使用道具 举报

全局:
GavinTao1219 发表于 2025-01-20 20:17:40
“你们两口子是合法移民,不代表肚子里的孩子也是合法移民!”
小孩h4也合法啊
回复

使用道具 举报

🔗
梦之啸 2025-1-21 12:33:12 | 只看该作者
全局:
Huanhuanxixi 发表于 2025-1-20 23:23
所以trump的意思就是,非绿卡或公民生的小孩not subject to jurisdiction咯,杀人放火零元购都不受管辖

看AI总结的,反正是挺有争议的,目前普遍观点是本土出生既是受管辖,所以是公民。看最高法这次会不会再推翻前例了:
The phrase "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" in the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution has been the subject of significant legal debate. Here’s a summary to help you understand its interpretation:

Historical Context: The 14th Amendment was ratified in 1868, primarily to grant citizenship to former slaves. The phrase "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" meant that those born in the U.S. who were not under the political jurisdiction of another country (like foreign diplomats) were granted citizenship1.

Supreme Court Rulings: One landmark case is United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898). The Court ruled that a child born in the U.S. to foreign parents who were permanent residents was a U.S. citizen, emphasizing that almost anyone born on U.S. soil is "subject to the jurisdiction" of the U.S., except children of foreign diplomats or enemy soldiers.

Modern Interpretations: Recent debates have questioned whether children born to undocumented immigrants should be considered U.S. citizens. However, the traditional interpretation upheld by the Supreme Court asserts that these children are indeed subject to U.S. jurisdiction and therefore entitled to citizenship3.
回复

使用道具 举报

🔗
staftermath 2025-1-21 12:35:21 | 只看该作者
全局:
梦之啸 发表于 2025-1-20 20:53
详细读了一下原文,主要观点就是:
理由:美国宪法第十四修正案规定:“所有在美国出生或归化的人,且受其 ...

感谢层主的认真分析。

参与一下讨论,我个人认为EO这个解释太牵强,虽然不至于直接被扔垃圾桶的程度,但感觉保守派的法官可能会强烈质疑。(我认为保守派的法官对于宪法的教条主义还是很强烈的)。

当然有一定几率拍川普马屁……
回复

使用道具 举报

您需要登录后才可以回帖 登录 | 注册账号
隐私提醒:
  • ☑ 禁止发布广告,拉群,贴个人联系方式:找人请去🔗同学同事飞友,拉群请去🔗拉群结伴,广告请去🔗跳蚤市场,和 🔗租房广告|找室友
  • ☑ 论坛内容在发帖 30 分钟内可以编辑,过后则不能删帖。为防止被骚扰甚至人肉,不要公开留微信等联系方式,如有需求请以论坛私信方式发送。
  • ☑ 干货版块可免费使用 🔗超级匿名:面经(美国面经、中国面经、数科面经、PM面经),抖包袱(美国、中国)和录取汇报、定位选校版
  • ☑ 查阅全站 🔗各种匿名方法

本版积分规则

>
快速回复 返回顶部 返回列表