本帖最后由 huanxiong4903 于 2012-8-13 21:58 编辑
<Guns, Germs and Steel> (1-37/665) #20 Week of Aug 6th1. Why did history unfold differently on differentcontinents? 2.The book’s emphasis is on the search for ultimate explanations, and on pushing back thechain of historical causation as far as possible. 3.Such narrowlyfocused accounts of world history suffer from three disadvantages. 4.Those historicalinequalities have cast long shadows on the modern world, because theliterate societies with metal tools have conquered or exterminated the othersocieties. 5.Yali radiated charisma and energy. 6.Don’t words such as “civilization,” and phrases such as “rise of civilization,”convey the false impression that civilization is good, tribal hunter-gatherersare miserable, and history for the past 13,000 years has involved progresstoward greater human happiness? In fact, I do not assume that industrializedstates are “better” than hunter-gatherer tribes, or that the abandonment of thehunter-gatherer lifestyle for iron-based statehood represents “progress,” orthat it has led to an increase in human happiness. 7.However, detailed archaeological studies have shown that complex irrigation systemsdid not accompany the rise of centralized bureaucracies but followed after aconsiderable lag. |