活跃农民
- 积分
- 609
- 大米
- 颗
- 鳄梨
- 个
- 水井
- 尺
- 蓝莓
- 颗
- 萝卜
- 根
- 小米
- 粒
- 学分
- 个
- 注册时间
- 2016-10-20
- 最后登录
- 1970-1-1
|
写了一条评论,主要谈到unfairness compete, 参考了前面关于乡村医院的论据. 1point 3 acres
. 1point3acres
I strongly oppose this rule: "Strengthening Wage Protections for the Temporary and Permanent Employment of Certain Aliens" by it stated the ineffective solution to protect jobs to US citizens. By significantly increasing the prevailing wage, you are looking at about 1/3 of the H1B visa applications will be affected. Some industries are highly dependent on workers under H1B visa, hospital in rural areas, tech industry, etc. By leveraging the prevailing wage by two level does not make sense for normal H1B applicants and PERM applicants since this introduced extreme unfairness. Take Greater Seattle Area as an example, according to the prevailing wage posted by DOL https://www.flcdatacenter.com/, the threshold before Oct 8, 2020 the software developers, application job wage was level 1: $92102, level 2: $113110, level 3: $134097, level 4: 155105. Now the new wage after Oct 8 is level 1: $139880, level 2: $167918, level 3: $195936, level 4: $223974. So as we can see since the percentile change, now we are expecting a level 1 (with no experience) or level 2 (with little experience, junior level) 's salary has to compete with the former level 3 or level 4, to be able to be qualified for H1B or PERM LCA filing. No companies will be able to offer such a salary since it's unfair to more senior employees. And with hospital in rural area for example, their offering salary was originally lower, therefore they are not attractive to US citizens and rely on foreign worker on H1B to support local medical service. If this rule is effective, they cannot afford the new way beyond level salary to employees, and this will get worse if other hospitals from big cities choose to raise their employees wages. As a result, rural hospitals will lose all their H1B employees and significantly impact the local medical and health services. This is also not going to work out for the current H1B holders. Take a junior employee with an already approved H1B visa as an example, he/she will get raised on job levels, getting an increased salary of course. However, as I previously mentioned, the new prevailing wage is creating a unfair compete against the next two levels above you. Which means a level 1 employee gets promoted to level 2, and gets a higher salary. However, now if he/she wants to renew H1B visa, now the requirement is to be at least 62th percentile, which is close to former prevailing wage's level 4 salary, this is the same as requiring a level 2 employee has the salary of level 4 employee in his/her company, which is totally unrealistic, and this is just not trying to keep the lower level jobs to US citizen. Instead, this is about creating an extreme unfairness across H1B holder and US citizen at the same job level. No matter how well or how much contribution the H1B worker brought to company, industry and United States. Simply because employer could not afford to pay a level 2 with a level 4 prevailing wage salary, the contributor has to leave the country no matter you look it as short term or long term, which is not doing any good to US economics, science and technology development, and job markets. |
|