请教一下这封推荐信的质量

如题，推荐人把他写的推荐信转给我，他是我的course instructor，想问下大家的意见，这封推荐信怎么样呢？
XX was an excellent student. He always had a positive attitude and displayed interest and eagerness in soaking up the concepts taught in class and learning as much as possible. His attendance, participation, and assignment record were impeccable. Not only did he complete all requested exercises on time, but he did an excellent job at addressing the technical challenges
presented to him. He would frequently ask insightful questions about the lecture content and showed engagement and motivation. One thing that impressed me quite a bit was that he wanted to learn a specific technique (phase field simulations) that was not initially part of the syllabus. However, he found out that I had done quite a bit of work on it and respectfully requested that it be added as part of the course. I was very satisfied with this display of initiative and self-assertiveness.
XX is a mature student, and he is ready for higher educational endeavors including scientific research of the highest quality. During the final project he chose to have a very fluid communication with me, much in the manner that I work with my own graduate students, so that he would be completing milestones set by me of increasing difficulty and complexity until having a very solid piece of work. This type of interaction is typical of a confident, self-reliant student, and I am sure that he will do a fantastic job in his next academic activities. He also did very well following the tutorial that the TA and I put together to teach the students how to use Quantum Espresso, one of the most popular electronic structure free-source codes available, which instructors often use as an entry level tool for doing density functional theory calculations. Despite the novelty of the subject for him, he quickly got himself acquainted with the software and the example and test runs that the TA designed for the students.
Based on his performance in my class, his level of maturity, and his work ethic, I would strongly recommend XX for graduate work in a US university.

一般推荐信都是不给你看的吧....

我是一颗土豆 发表于 2020-12-31 23:43
在课程推中质量算高的，但只是课程推的话没法算强推。

非杠，单纯想请教下为啥课程推不算强推呢？（感觉对phd是这样，但是想问下是不是master也是）

算强推吧，但是你的instructor 有名吗。。。 一般老师会在 draft 里写点他教了多少年， 有啥学生啥的。。如果就是一般的instructor，ap或者还不是ap的话 那就会变成平推了

感覺應該要多點實例證明你的優點 目前看起來只是一堆形容詞稱讚你而已 加米加米

我感觉还行吧，有几个小例子，程度应该比平推好一点吧。

算是强推吧，但是依旧是课上的interaction，如果有科研或者项目相关的合作说服力会更强

比较高评价的模板！棒

如果你只上过ta的课，这种推荐信算是非常positive的letter了，大多数美国老师写的课程推荐信都比这个要弱。

这老师好好呀，还给你看推荐信

这已经很高质量了。我之前的老师给我写的推荐信都是一两段话随便套模板敷衍一下。他也好心发给我看了。
. ----
不然你有什么好的例子，你写好给你老师叫他帮你把例子加进去？写一个清单的成就叫他能不能把这些成就列进去。你自己总结写写，减轻老师的负担。老师也开心。你也开心。