OPT NEW STEM 10/19正式进入公示!!!!!!!，准备好评论吧小伙伴们

anna-1080 发表于 2015-10-27 01:21
哪位大神给反驳下？

此人逻辑有点问题，反驳一个脑子不清楚的人你得疯狂才行

International students should leave America! Stop taking jobs and opportunities away from American people!
America is for Americans! The whole opt program is used by Obama administration to transform the demographics to achieve his liberal agenda.
I have called my congressman to stop the new opt stem rule and I am happy that the Washington technology worker Alliance has filed the appeal to challenge the court's decision
We will not just abolish opt extension. We will also abolish H1b visa and the regular opt program. Indians and Chinese should go back to India and China!

zhuniuniu 发表于 2015-10-17 05:54
强烈支持啊！
总是说我们中国人漠不关心政治，我想那是因为一些大家都不好说出口的原因，那是因为我们根本 ...

The opt extension rule is total madness. Too many bright American students in STEM fields cannot find jobs because there are too many indians and chinese taking away our jobs. America is for Americans, not for foreign students! We will try all our efforts to call our congressman to abolish the whole opt and H1b visa which only serve to depress US workers' salaries.   

我已经投出我宝贵的一票

opt是什么？ 是不是说在那段时间可以和h1b身份一样工作？ 还是说只能实习，不能转正？

johnM 发表于 2015-10-28 05:57
International students should leave America! Stop taking jobs and opportunities away from American p ...

politically incorrect： only native American should stay, all others should go back to where their ancestors belonged to!

Politically correct: Let Indian and Chinese get better training here, they will create job for American when they go back to their home countries.

johnM 发表于 2015-10-28 06:06
The opt extension rule is total madness. Too many bright American students in STEM fields cannot f ...

politically incorrect: their jobs are taken away because they are either not bright or not hard working enough!

Politically correct: OPT strengthen American competitive edge and bilaterally beneficent for both American and non-American!

Which one will you choose ? Guess truth telling is not always welcomed    

jeff_xu001 发表于 2015-10-28 09:07
politically incorrect: their jobs are taken away because they are either not bright or not hard wo ...

Let me dispute your arguments:
"only native American should stay, all others should go back to where their ancestors belonged to!"

You are right that US was founded by immigrants but it does not mean US must hold this label forever. This is time for US government
to care about American People. I assume you are chinese, how will you feel if Chinese government wants to take in an endless flood of
foreign guest workers from North korea, Vietnam or Mongolia?

"Let Indian and Chinese get better training here, they will create job for American when they go back to their home countries"
You are using the same argument of lobbying groups of Wall Street and Silicon Valley.
You may get different conclusions by examining different sets of data.
Even if there is growth, only giant corporations enjoy it. Ordinary American do not feel it

"their jobs are taken away because they are either not bright or not hard working enough":
I will refer you to the news where US workers in Disney were displaced by H1b holders receiving lower wage
Those displaced US workers by H1b holders are all hardworking people and they were fired because of the treacherous guest worker programs
like H1b and opt

"OPT strengthen American competitive edge and bilaterally beneficent for both American and non-American!"

As I said, OPT only increases profitability of giant corporations and ordinary American people do not feel it.
Those corrupt politicans like Marco Rubio, Ted Cruz, Jeb Bush and Hillary Clinton are using the same talking point to deceive
American People and We will never be convinced again!

I will refer you to the news where US workers in Disney were displaced by H1b holders receiving lower wage ？ that sounds ridiculous, and I am personally  in favor of strengthening H1B check

However, pls take the following points into your account:

(1) OPT students are generally paid at least equally as their American counterparts in Hi-tech companies, big or small in size
(2) Companies that hire OPT students would have to pay more resources in hiring them, are they any kind of charity organizations?

sense anything there? the truth is: they do so due to the lack of sufficient supply of qualified domestic talents!

so, pls stop complaining and do some study in sharpening your competitive advantages! hardworking spirit is what makes US a great nation not protection!  
  

这周末要好好写几条论点
大家也加油啊
要写出issue的风范