EB1B Petition NSC - Received NOID

sillyboy 发表于 2021-4-8 08:08
杀手从来没有离开，只会越来越多。NSC从来都是1000没啥奇怪的，奇怪的是楼主申请EB1B，竟然被要求1000次c ...

我就是说最近eb1b最近很多被要求1000…都是同样的句子。

jingjing1012 发表于 2021-4-8 08:24
感觉抓住了你的citation然后再找其他的毛病，回复的意义不大，还是选择refile吧。ME专业上1000真的是很难的 ...

拿到tenure的ME教授差不多才能达到1000次引用

给楼主提供个数据点，EB1B, NSC, 直接PP， 也是拿到了NOID。信里说满足了三条标准(review, publication, contribution), 但是final merits 没通过. 回复后approve。回复时深挖了每个claim。 我当时做的是对review，强调了guest editor，conference chair的经历，同时给审过的期刊editor 要证明信，列出review的比较好的期刊的rank。对publication，强调了每篇文章在专业排的rank。对contribution，深挖了引用（刚过100)，大概找了20个左右重要的引用着重强调，同时列出引用中的作者单位rank（university rank), 期刊rank，比较牛的作者。又找引用我文章的人增加了两封推荐信。不知道楼主是自己DIY 还是找律师，我是找的律师，提交的版本对这些东西都有提到，但大部分都是泛泛来谈，我在回复中把这些泛泛的语言都变成了具体的表格和数字，个人觉得这是最有帮助的。祝楼主好运。btw， 我是2019年底申请的case, 也是mechanical相关专业，publication 只有13篇 （7篇一作），review ~50.

Thanks all . . I really appreciate all your replies, it's giving me some hope in drafting reply to services.

for citations, I'm getting letters from journal editors mentioning that journals are top ranking but field itself is slow moving. And they consider me expert thus invite consistently for reviews.

I have got two international letters, trying to get few more.

so far I got: (all independent letters)

US:
3 program managers who manage research in the area
1 journal editor from US
1 private company head who is using my patented technology
1 US university professor who used my technology
1 lab scientist who is using my technology

Europe:
1 researcher who used my technology and invited me to give seminar there
1 journal editor

Asia:
Submitted one letter with original petition

with original petition + reply to NOID, I'll have:

US: 8
International : 3

sorry, I forgot to add letter from head of highest rank organization in field about international award that I received.

so total :
US: 9
International : 3