求助transfer RFE 专家信有模版吗？或成功失败case

H1B transfer被RFE，理由是Special Occupation，楼主职位是marketing research analyst 被RFE很多的title。。研究了很多地里的帖子之后找了有industrial经验了解也了解我所在电商行业的研究生教授，人非常好了解情况后愿意帮我写这个信
但问了我司律师没有模版，教授想知道要写到哪些点能让这个信起作用。
想问大家律师有提供模板么？ 或者哪里可以找到rfe专家信被拒或被接受的例子参考？

我查了一些expert opinion letter被拒的理由，感觉很坑
要教授亲自到过worksite？要补充好job description合理；还要cite research？

In recent months, the USCIS appears largely to have stopped giving much weight to expert opinion letters in the H1B specialty occupation context. The USCIS routinely is dismissing expert opinion letters as reliable evidence, based on one or more of the following factors.

• The expert did not physically visit the beneficiary’s worksite and observe the beneficiary performing the duties of the position; therefore, the expert does not have sufficient knowledge of the job to provide an accurate evaluation.
• The expert’s opinion was limited to the information provided by the petitioner, and the job description did not provide sufficient information to establish the details of the position; therefore, the expert cannot adequately evaluate the position.
• The expert has not cited the research that was used as a basis for the conclusion that the proffered position is a specialty occupation.
• The expert’s opinion is not in line with the other information on the record; therefore, USCIS is giving less weight to the opinion.
  

先感谢🙏 在异国他乡工作生活都太不容易了～～～先祝大家工作签证都顺顺利利！

模版和花钱意义不大，自己写。教授只能证明岗位需要学历和相关学术背景。

The expert did not physically visit the beneficiary’s worksite and observe the beneficiary performing the duties of the position; therefore, the expert does not have sufficient knowledge of the job to provide an accurate evaluation.

这句话怎么破，除非现在的老板不然谁能“physically visit the beneficiary’s worksite and observe the beneficiary performing the duties of the position”？

同求助专家信，楼主有思路了吗

michellehuang 发表于 2019-7-5 06:37
同求助专家信，楼主有思路了吗

没有模版哈 参考这个 https://www.murthy.com/2018/03/0 ... b-petition-filings/  要写出给力的专家信真的不容易 要自己做很多research 教授配合 而且移民局还是总能挑刺

感谢楼主！！请问个小问题，letter一开始怎么称呼对方比较合适呢？Dear USCIS？

michellehuang 发表于 2019-7-7 08:13
感谢楼主！！请问个小问题，letter一开始怎么称呼对方比较合适呢？Dear USCIS？

. ----To Whom It May Concern 感觉好些

lz后来怎么处理的