活跃农民
- 积分
- 386
- 大米
- 颗
- 鳄梨
- 个
- 水井
- 尺
- 蓝莓
- 颗
- 萝卜
- 根
- 小米
- 粒
- 学分
- 个
- 注册时间
- 2021-3-26
- 最后登录
- 1970-1-1
|
用GPT写的:
. Χ
H-1B $103,265 Fee:Comment Strategy
核心主张(Core Theory)
DHS 没有充分证明它有 statutory authority 收取 $103,265,也没有证明这是真正的 regulatory fee,而不是变相的 tax / revenue measure。. 1point 3 acres
重点不是单纯说“太贵、不公平”,而是要建立一个 APA litigation record:让 DHS 必须逐项回答这些问题。
⸻
1. Statutory Authority — DHS 到底凭什么收?
最重要的问题。
DHS 依赖 INA §286(m), 8 U.S.C. §1356(m) 等 authority。. ----
. 1point 3acres
Comment 应要求 DHS 明确说明:
* 哪一条 statute 授权收 $103,265?
* 为什么可以针对 H-1B employers 单独收这么高?
* 为什么可以用 H-1B 的钱支付其他 agencies 的费用?
* 为什么 Congress 没有明确授权的情况下,DHS 可以创造这种规模的 financial burden?
核心句:
DHS must identify the specific statutory authority that authorizes a $103,265 charge imposed specifically on cap-subject H-1B petitioners.
⸻
2. Fee vs. Tax — 这到底是 fee 还是 tax?
这是第二个核心。
DHS 预计一年产生约 $8.8 billion。
而钱并不只是用于处理这个 H-1B petition,而是涉及:
* USCIS
* ICE
* CBP
* EOIR
* DOL. 1point3acres
* DOS.--
所以问题是:
. check 1point3acres for more.
如果一个 H-1B petition 的 processing cost 并没有接近 $103,265,为什么这仍然叫 fee?.google и
. Χ
应该要求 DHS 证明:
Amount charged ↔ Government service / regulatory cost
之间到底有什么合理关系。
尤其要问:
. From 1point 3acres bbs
Why should a single H-1B petitioner bear costs that are not directly attributable to adjudicating that petition?
⸻
3. Interagency Cost-Shifting — 为什么 H-1B 要替其他项目买单?
这是一个非常具体、很值得写进 comment 的 point。
. ----
例如 proposed allocation 包括:. 1point3acres.com
* EOIR:约 $2.96B
* ICE:约 $1.05B
* DOL:约 $1.21B
* DOS:约 $484M
* CBP:约 $76M
而 DOL 的资金又涉及:
* PERM
* H-2A
* H-2B/CW-1
* Wage & Hour
* 其他 labor enforcement
所以可以直接问:.1point3acres
What is the statutory and factual nexus between these activities and the individual H-1B petition being charged $103,265?
特别是:
Why should H-1B employers subsidize unrelated immigration programs and enforcement activities?. From 1point 3acres bbs
⸻
.
4. $103,265 是怎么算出来的?
不要只说“数字太高”。
要求 DHS show its math。
Comment 可以要求 disclosure:
* 每一项 cost 是什么?
* 哪些 costs 被纳入?
* 哪些被排除?
* 各 agency 怎么分摊?
* 为什么是 $103,265 而不是 $20K、$30K、$50K?
* 这个数字与实际 H-1B adjudication cost 有什么关系?
核心:
DHS must demonstrate the factual and mathematical basis for the $103,265 amount.
如果无法解释数字来源,会削弱 reasoned decisionmaking。
⸻
. 1point 3 acres
5. 85,000 petitions assumption
DHS 的 revenue model 大致建立在:
85,000 × $103,265 ≈ $8.78B
. check 1point3acres for more.
但是问题是:.1point3acres
高额 fee 本身会减少 H-1B filings。
所以需要 DHS 分析:. 1point3acres
* 85K petitions ..
* 75K
* 65K
* 50K
* 40K
* 30K
分别会产生多少 revenue。
也就是说:
.1point3acres
DHS cannot simply assume a stable filing volume when the rule itself is expected to substantially change employer behavior.
.--
这是一个很好的 economic analysis / arbitrary-and-capricious point。
⸻
6. DHS 到底是 Cost Recovery 还是 Deterrence?. 1point3acres
这个问题非常重要。
.google и
如果目的是真正的:
Cost Recovery
那么:
为什么需要 $103,265?
-baidu 1point3acres
但如果真正目的包括:
. 1point3acres.com
Deterring employers from using H-1B
. check 1point3acres for more.
那么 DHS 就应该解释:
为什么一个 massive six-figure fee 是合理、有效且必要的 policy instrument?
而不是把一个 deterrence mechanism 包装成普通 processing fee。
⸻
7. “Ability to Pay” 理论有问题
DHS 的一个重要逻辑是:
H-1B employers 有能力支付 H-1B worker 的 salary,所以也有能力支付这个 fee。. From 1point 3acres bbs
可以直接反驳:-baidu 1point3acres
Ability to pay salary ≠ ability to pay an additional $103,265 government charge.
. check 1point3acres for more.. From 1point 3acres bbs
尤其:
* startup
* small business
* nonprofit
* university
* research organization
可能完全不同。
要求 DHS 提供 empirical evidence,而不是 assumption。
⸻
8. Small Business Impact.google и
这是一个非常强的 factual record。
. 1point3acres
DHS 自己预计大约 11,000 个 small entities 会受到 significant economic impact。
所以应该问:. .и
如果 DHS 自己的 analysis 表明大量 small businesses 会受到重大影响,为什么仍然选择一个 uniform $103,265 fee?
然后要求 DHS 分析 alternatives:
* Small-business exemption
* Reduced fee
* Graduated fee
* Startup exemption
* Nonprofit exemption
* Wage-based fee
⸻
9. 为什么一个 startup 和 Microsoft 要交一样?
. Χ
这是对 uniform fee 的具体 challenge。
.1point3acres
一个:
3-person startup → 1 H-1B employee
和一个:
大型 multinational → hundreds/thousands of employees
都可能承担同样的 $103,265。
所以要求 DHS 解释:
Why is a flat six-figure fee rational when employers’ ability to absorb the cost varies dramatically?
-baidu 1point3acres
⸻
10. U.S. Master’s / Advanced Degree Exemption
DHS 还把 H-1B advanced-degree exemption 纳入这个 fee。
Congress 本身创造了:
. 1point3acres.com
INA §214(g)(5)(C)
这个 advanced-degree allocation。-baidu 1point3acres
因此应要求 DHS 分析:
Congress specifically created additional H-1B numbers for U.S. advanced-degree beneficiaries. Why is imposing a $103,265 additional barrier consistent with that congressional policy?
不是简单说“违法”,而是要求 DHS address the statutory interaction。
⸻
11. Borjas Study — “Willingness to Pay” ≠ Government Authority
如果 DHS 使用经济研究证明:
Employers may be willing to pay $100K–$200K for an H-1B worker..1point3acres
Comment 应指出:
. Χ
Employer willingness to pay does not establish statutory authority to impose the charge.
两个完全不同的问题:
. From 1point 3acres bbs
Economic value ≠ Legal authority
. Χ
而且要问研究是否考虑:
* startups
* small employers
* nonprofits
* universities
* different wage levels ..
* different industries
⸻
12. Historical Practice — Why is DHS doing something unprecedented?
NPRM 本身承认,这种做法与 DHS historically 的 fee-setting practice 有明显区别。
. 1point3acres
因此问:.
If §286(m) has always authorized this approach, why has DHS never previously used it to impose a fee on one immigration population to fund broad activities across multiple agencies?. From 1point 3acres bbs
然后:
.1point3acres
What changed in the statute, case law, or agency interpretation?
这是很好的 reasoned explanation issue。
⸻
13. Alternatives Analysis
这是 APA comment 里一定要有的。.google и
要求 DHS 认真比较:
.1point3acres
Alternative A: 普通 cost-based fee
Alternative B: Moderate fee spread across broader population. 1point 3acres
Alternative C: Graduated H-1B fee
Alternative D: Wage-based fee
Alternative E: Small-business/startup exemption
Alternative F: 只让 H-1B petitioners 支付真正 attributable to H-1B 的 costs
Alternative G: Congress appropriations
核心不是说 DHS 必须选择你的 alternative。 ..
. 1point3acres.com
而是:
. check 1point3acres for more.
DHS must meaningfully consider less burdensome alternatives before adopting an unprecedented six-figure charge.
.1point3acres
⸻. 1point3acres
14. Economic Consequences
要求 DHS 更完整分析:. Waral dи,
* H-1B filings 减少. ----
* jobs moved overseas
* companies hire abroad instead
* startup formation
* U.S. research
* universities
* STEM pipeline
* wages. 1point3acres.com
* tax revenue
* U.S. workers working alongside H-1B employees
尤其要求 DHS 分析:
Does the rule actually achieve its stated objective, or does it simply shift employment outside the United States?
⸻
15. Revenue Model 的 Circularity.google и
这是最后一个很漂亮的 argument:
DHS 想用 H-1B fee 获得 $8.8B。
..
但是:
Fee ↑ → H-1B demand ↓ → petitions ↓ → revenue ↓
所以要求 DHS 做 sensitivity analysis。
.--
如果 petitions 只有 50K:
50,000 × $103,265 ≈ $5.16B. 1point 3 acres
.1point3acres
如果只有 30K:
. 1point3acres.com
≈ $3.10B
那么原本要靠这笔钱支持的 EOIR、ICE、DOL 等项目怎么办? |
|