EB1B NOID回复

大家好，我的EB1B NOID回复 （给IO）准备的差不多了。但是有几个IO提出的问题不知道怎么答复。可以不答复吗？大家有什么建议？多谢了！ 原帖在 thread-642412-1-1（抱歉没有权限发URL）

Questions Regarding Peer Review:
Q1: The record shows that the beneficiary served as a reviewer in the academic field, but the evidence does not establish that his participation in the widespread peer-view process (a routine process in the field relying on many scientists) exceeds that of other researchers or reflects international recognition.
目前review7篇，不知名杂志。

Questions Regarding Citations:
Q1: The record shows that the beneficiary has published 13 scholarly papers in the academic field that have garnered 157 citations (not excluding self-citations), but you have not demonstrated how this frequency of citations to his work reflects that he is recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic field. You have not provided, for example, information that compares his citations with those of internationally recognized researchers in the field.

Q2. Although citations show that the beneficiary’s research has received some attention, you have not established that the frequency of citations to the beneficiary’s work set him apart from the rest of the academic field. As such, submit Google Scholar profiles of outstanding researchers in his specific fields, his letter of recommendation authors and co-authors

Q3. It must be noted that the beneficiary has not published any research in the academic field since 2016, which coincides with his employment at your company. This establishes that the beneficiary has only been making contributions to your company and that he has not been active in the academic field for several years.

Q4. While footnoted citations have values in showing that other researchers have referred to the beneficiary’s work, those citations do not elevate the beneficiary above the countless other published researchers whose work is cited in thousands of scholarly journals every year.

个让人感觉都不难回复吧，review就是找杂志编辑写封信，citation 就是找几个不如你的人的GS, 最好是ap以上的人，说说引用的全球性，做个油灯图，挑几个notable 的引用，深挖一下

单位的工作没有文章发表，可以说说其他方式的贡献，专利，内部报告，保密性的设计文件，找领导要个证明。

谢谢分享！持续关注！也准备申请

Haishengzhang 发表于 2020-07-14 20:01:02
谢谢分享！持续关注！也准备申请

你好老哥，这里也见到你了

披头散发 发表于 2020-07-16 07:56:49
你好老哥，这里也见到你了

会一直在这里，不然一个人折腾太痛苦了

Haishengzhang 发表于 2020-7-16 23:08
会一直在这里，不然一个人折腾太痛苦了

嗯嗯，抱歉之前你在WX里问的J转O的问题我不知道，不过要是有其他我能帮忙的肯定义不容辞

披头散发 发表于 2020-07-16 11:31:50
嗯嗯，抱歉之前你在WX里问的J转O的问题我不知道，不过要是有其他我能帮忙的肯定义不容辞

非常感谢！！！

收到了跟楼主类似的notice，请问楼主是怎么回复下面两个问题的呀？
1. "notexcludingself-citations"：有提供这种统计功能的网站吗？在googlescholar和webofscience上都没有找到
2. "You have not provided for example information that compares his citations with those of internationally recognized researchers in the field"